Panasonic HDC-SD20 Camcorder Review

by Kaitlyn Chantry
Published on Apr 3, 2009 8:32 AM

 
Intro Product Tour
Color & Noise Performance Motion & Sharpness Performance
Low Light Performance Compression & Media
Manual Controls Still Features
Handling & Use Playback & Connectivity
Audio & Other Features Canon HF20 Comparison
Sanyo VPC-HD2000 Comparison
Sony MHS-CM1 Comparison
Conclusion Photo Gallery
Specs and Ratings


Panasonic HDC-SD20 versus Sony MHS-CM1
• The Sony is significantly cheaper and less feature-filled than the Panasonic
• Panasonic is the better performer in most regards, especially in motion
• Both are easy to use, but the Panasonic has more beginner-friendly bonus features
Sanyo VPC-HD2000 Comparison (Page 14 of 17) Conclusion

If you're left wondering whether the Canon HF20 is worth the $300 you would have to pay above the price of the SD20, also consider whether the SD20 is worth the $350 you would have to pay above the Sony Webbie HD MHS-CM1. For video performance, the SD20 certainly outperforms the Webbie in nearly every regard. The Webbie is quite a bit sharper, but the motion artifacting is pretty atrocious compared to the relatively clear video of the SD20. Even the huge 1/2.5-inch sensor does no better at producing brighter footage in low light. While both are easy to use, the SD20 comes packed with all those great iA technologies, like AF/AE Tracking.

If you're trying to decide between the Sony MHS-CM1 and the Panasonic HDC-SD20, you probably aren't all that interested in manual image adjustments like shutter speed and gain, but remember that you can always shoot in auto mode on the SD20; you can't add manual controls to the Webbie. For $350, you'll have incredibly superior video quality and the opportunity to learn more advanced videography in the future.

  Comparison Specs
 
  Panasonic HDC-SD20 Sony MHS-CM1
Price $549 $199
Primary Recording Media SD/SDHC memory card Memory Stick PRO Duo
Secondary Recording Media None 12 MB of internal memory
(mostly used for internal software)
Image Sensor 1/6-inch CMOS 1/2.5-inch CMOS
Effective Pixel Count 1.17 megapixels (video)
1.17 megapixels (stills)
2.07 megapixels (video)
2.07 megapixels (stills)
Mic Input No No
LCD/Viewfinder 2.7-inch LCD with
230,400-pixel resolution
2.5-inch LCD with
153,000-pixel resolution
Weight 327g (including battery) 210g (including battery)
Dimensions 67 x 64 x 127mm 43 x 61 x 105mm
HD Yes Yes
Optical Zoom 16x 5x
Frame Rates 1080/60i, Digital Cinema (24p)
(not natively progressive)
1080/30p
(native progressive)
Image Stabilization Optical None

 

 

  Scores
  Panasonic HDC-SD20 Sony MHS-CM1
Color 7.87 7.04
Noise 9.9 5.27
Video Sharpness 7.97 11.66
Low Light Sensitivity 0.97 0.45
Low Light Color 3.72 7.03
Low Light Noise 12.95 7.08
Ease of Use 7.25 6.0
Battery Life 87 min, 46 sec 124 min, 16 sec
Stabilization 5.60 0.0 (no stabilization feature)

 

  Close-Up Color Comparisons
   
  Ideal Panasonic HDC-SD20 Sony MHS-CM1
Red
Skin
Tone 2

 

Battery Life Comparisons

 



<< Sanyo VPC-HD2000 Comparison | Conclusion >>